Base rate

Technical trading rules on BTCUSD: what 17,167 backtests show

By Justin JaegerPublished Updated

BTCUSD: 17,167 backtests of RSI, MACD, Donchian, squeeze and moving-average rules with macro filters, full history after costs. 11.7% beat cash and 1.7% beat buy-and-hold; median Sharpe −0.94. The strongest combination by median was Donchian breakout rules on daily bars (+0.76).

17,167 Bitcoin rule backtests: 11.7% beat cash, 1.7% beat holding

Key numbers

MeasureValue
Backtests17,167
Distinct strategies5,917
Symbols1
Median Sharpe−0.94
10th to 90th percentile−2.51 to +0.05
Beat cash (Sharpe above 0)11.7%
Sharpe above 10.16%
Beat buy-and-hold1.7%
Median trades306
Of those with positive returns: still positive after 202353%

By timeframe and rule

TimeframeRule familyBacktestsMedian SharpeBeat cashBeat buy-and-hold
15-minuteDonchian breakout rules1715−1.290%0%
15-minuteMACD crossover rules1627−2.200%0%
15-minuteRSI zone rules1723−2.100%0%
15-minuteMoving-average crossover rules1664−0.4318%1%
15-minuteBollinger squeeze rules1679−1.790%0%
1-hourDonchian breakout rules1703−0.4213%0%
1-hourMACD crossover rules1631−0.1332%1%
1-hourRSI zone rules1815−1.070%0%
1-hourMoving-average crossover rules1609−0.0942%12%
1-hourBollinger squeeze rules1672−0.626%0%
4-hourDonchian breakout rules40+0.6895%57%
4-hourMACD crossover rules38−0.325%0%
4-hourRSI zone rules49−0.4110%0%
4-hourMoving-average crossover rules33+0.4379%36%
4-hourBollinger squeeze rules39+0.1477%0%
dailyDonchian breakout rules42+0.7693%69%
dailyMACD crossover rules36+0.2075%11%
dailyRSI zone rules38−0.0150%0%
dailyBollinger squeeze rules13+0.37100%8%

By filter family

Filter familyBacktestsMedian SharpeBeat cash
liquidity (money supply, balance sheets)2,286−0.7811.2%
market data (VIX, indices, commodities)4,950−0.8715.8%
crypto market data1,320−0.9212.4%
interest rates and yield curve2,647−0.9312.2%
sentiment and surveys2,883−1.068.3%
macro releases (CPI, PMI, payrolls ...)3,081−1.098.2%

How to use this

Before you backtest a technical rule on BTCUSD, look up the median for that rule and timeframe. A result far above it after many tries is more likely luck than an edge. Your agent can run the same check on its own result with the check_backtest tool.

Caveats

In-sample, not validated on new data: full-history backtests after retail costs, Sharpe minus a 4% cash rate. "Still positive after 2023" only counts variants with positive returns over the full history, which includes 2023–2026, and 2023–2026 were rising markets, so read it as an upper bound. Monthly macro filters were applied 1–3 weeks before publication in these backtests, which flatters them. Some price files had data errors.

Terms used: in-sample upper bound, trial count, dead end.

Before your next backtest

Let your AI check how ideas like yours did before it runs a single test. In our pilot, agents that checked first spent 1% of their backtests on known dead ends instead of 15%, and every backtest not wasted is time and tokens you keep. Cite this entry as ER-LIB-BTCUSD, as of 2026-11-01.

Related evidence

Questions

Do technical indicators work on BTCUSD?

BTCUSD: 17,167 backtests of RSI, MACD, Donchian, squeeze and moving-average rules with macro filters, full history after costs. 11.7% beat cash and 1.7% beat buy-and-hold; median Sharpe −0.94. The strongest combination by median was Donchian breakout rules on daily bars (+0.76).

Is this investment advice?

No. Research statistics only.