Evidence

336,445 technical-rule backtests: the in-sample upper bound

By Justin JaegerPublished Updated

Only 4.3% of 336,445 classic technical-rule backtests beat cash after retail costs, even over the full history; forex rules almost never did.

Win often or win big? 58,022 profitable backtests
282,348 long backtests. Zero had a Sharpe above 1
336,332 indicator backtests: 4.3% beat cash, 66 reached a Sharpe above 1

See what a rule typically earned before you backtest it yourself, and judge your best result against hundreds of variants. RSI, MACD, Donchian, moving-average and squeeze rules, combined with macro filters, on 557 symbols from 15-minute to daily bars. Full history, after costs.

By rule family

Rule familyBacktestsBeat cashMedian Sharpe
RSI zone rules84,4813.8%−1.09
MACD crossover rules81,5743.8%−1.12
Donchian breakout rules75,8654.6%−0.90
Bollinger squeeze rules46,9280.7%−1.61
Moving-average crossover rules38,7619.3%−0.84
Turtle soup (false breakout) rules8,8369.8%−0.92

By market and timeframe

Market · timeframeBacktestsBeat cashMedian Sharpe
stocks, indices and ETFs · 15-minute46,0020.9%−1.65
stocks, indices and ETFs · daily41,40512.6%−0.25
stocks, indices and ETFs · 1-hour68,0302.6%−0.83
stocks, indices and ETFs · 4-hour48,6467.1%−0.48
forex · 15-minute25,5680.0%−4.66
forex · daily10,1740.0%−1.62
forex · 1-hour39,7660.1%−3.21
forex · 4-hour27,6230.2%−2.76
crypto · 15-minute13,3345.2%−1.38
crypto · daily12356.9%+0.03
crypto · 1-hour15,26617.8%−0.46
crypto · 4-hour50837.8%−0.16

Rule × market × timeframe

Rule · market · timeframeBacktestsBeat cashMedian Sharpe
Donchian breakout rules · crypto · 15-minute3,0180.3%−1.23
Donchian breakout rules · crypto · 1-hour3,4258.6%−0.46
Donchian breakout rules · ETFs · 15-minute5420.0%−2.07
Donchian breakout rules · ETFs · 1-hour5160.2%−0.95
Donchian breakout rules · ETFs · 4-hour5065.7%−0.52
Donchian breakout rules · ETFs · daily51412.3%−0.36
Donchian breakout rules · forex · 15-minute4,9920.0%−4.91
Donchian breakout rules · forex · 1-hour6,0180.0%−3.05
Donchian breakout rules · forex · 4-hour3,3140.0%−2.48
Donchian breakout rules · forex · daily2,9710.3%−1.46
Donchian breakout rules · US stocks · 15-minute10,7210.2%−1.60
Donchian breakout rules · US stocks · 1-hour11,3152.4%−0.81
Donchian breakout rules · US stocks · 4-hour10,9336.1%−0.51
Donchian breakout rules · US stocks · daily13,37714.1%−0.25
MACD crossover rules · crypto · 15-minute2,9000.0%−1.82
MACD crossover rules · crypto · 1-hour3,29919.6%−0.31
MACD crossover rules · ETFs · 15-minute5110.0%−3.37
MACD crossover rules · ETFs · 1-hour5070.4%−1.36
MACD crossover rules · ETFs · 4-hour4960.6%−0.83
MACD crossover rules · ETFs · daily5109.0%−0.36
MACD crossover rules · forex · 15-minute4,8170.0%−4.23
MACD crossover rules · forex · 1-hour6,1650.0%−3.98
MACD crossover rules · forex · 4-hour3,4900.7%−3.18
MACD crossover rules · forex · daily3,0830.0%−1.84
MACD crossover rules · US stocks · 15-minute10,9650.0%−2.24
MACD crossover rules · US stocks · 1-hour11,7231.4%−1.04
MACD crossover rules · US stocks · 4-hour11,4352.8%−0.67
MACD crossover rules · US stocks · daily13,29712.0%−0.27
RSI zone rules · crypto · 15-minute3,1170.0%−1.76
RSI zone rules · crypto · 1-hour3,6430.8%−0.77
RSI zone rules · ETFs · 15-minute5380.0%−3.13
RSI zone rules · ETFs · 1-hour5420.0%−1.38
RSI zone rules · ETFs · 4-hour5312.1%−0.78
RSI zone rules · ETFs · daily5093.5%−0.30
RSI zone rules · forex · 15-minute5,4120.0%−5.83
RSI zone rules · forex · 1-hour6,5770.0%−4.01
RSI zone rules · forex · 4-hour3,7240.1%−3.26
RSI zone rules · forex · daily3,2150.1%−1.55
RSI zone rules · US stocks · 15-minute11,0210.4%−1.93
RSI zone rules · US stocks · 1-hour12,0100.4%−0.98
RSI zone rules · US stocks · 4-hour11,7035.1%−0.58
RSI zone rules · US stocks · daily14,05614.5%−0.22
Moving-average crossover rules · crypto · 15-minute2,96421.8%−0.39
Moving-average crossover rules · crypto · 1-hour3,29644.7%−0.05
Moving-average crossover rules · ETFs · 15-minute3940.0%−1.32
Moving-average crossover rules · ETFs · 1-hour4461.6%−0.78
Moving-average crossover rules · ETFs · 4-hour3672.5%−0.47
Moving-average crossover rules · ETFs · daily3759.6%−0.39
Moving-average crossover rules · forex · 15-minute4,8200.0%−3.94
Moving-average crossover rules · forex · 1-hour5,3330.0%−2.64
Moving-average crossover rules · forex · 4-hour2,9120.1%−1.99
Moving-average crossover rules · forex · daily2,2360.6%−1.33
Moving-average crossover rules · US stocks · 15-minute8,0621.4%−1.09
Moving-average crossover rules · US stocks · 1-hour7,9864.2%−0.60
Moving-average crossover rules · US stocks · 4-hour5,99610.6%−0.36
Moving-average crossover rules · US stocks · daily9,33916.4%−0.24
Bollinger squeeze rules · crypto · 15-minute3,0030.0%−1.73
Bollinger squeeze rules · crypto · 1-hour3,3803.2%−0.69
Bollinger squeeze rules · ETFs · 15-minute3080.0%−2.69
Bollinger squeeze rules · ETFs · 1-hour4490.2%−1.50
Bollinger squeeze rules · ETFs · 4-hour4240.0%−1.24
Bollinger squeeze rules · ETFs · daily3660.8%−1.34
Bollinger squeeze rules · forex · 15-minute3,4760.0%−5.32
Bollinger squeeze rules · forex · 1-hour5,1750.2%−3.93
Bollinger squeeze rules · forex · 4-hour2,9550.0%−3.20
Bollinger squeeze rules · forex · daily2,6640.0%−2.25
Bollinger squeeze rules · US stocks · 15-minute7,5200.1%−2.19
Bollinger squeeze rules · US stocks · 1-hour10,4950.5%−1.37
Bollinger squeeze rules · US stocks · 4-hour8,6470.9%−1.07
Bollinger squeeze rules · US stocks · daily10,2470.9%−0.73

Also by symbol: BTCUSD, EURUSD, AAPL and more. Do filters help? See the filter study.

Caveats

In-sample results: the most favourable view. Sharpe subtracts a 4% cash rate.

Before your next backtest

Let your AI check how ideas like yours did before it runs a single test. In our pilot, agents that checked first spent 1% of their backtests on known dead ends instead of 15%, and every backtest not wasted is time and tokens you keep. Cite this entry as ER-IS, as of 2026-11-01.

Questions

Do technical indicators work?

Rarely after costs: only 4.3% of 336,445 backtests beat cash even in hindsight.