Evidence

Trading strategy dead ends: idea classes that keep failing after costs

By Justin JaegerPublished Updated

7 idea classes are dead ends in the register as of 2026-11-01, including calendar effects and lead-lag signals on US equities and intraday timing rules.

89,101 scalping backtests: how many survive costs?

Every idea class on this page failed again and again after costs. Skip them, and the backtests you save go to ideas with a chance.

Out-of-sample dead ends

Fewer than 20% of tests beat the benchmark and the median result was clearly negative.

Idea classTestsBeat benchmarkMedian Sharpe vs bm
Calendar effects · single stocks340%−1.47
Calendar effects · US equities5317%−0.90
Lead-lag signals · international equities307%−0.21
Lead-lag signals · US equities28917%−0.23
Combined signals · multi-asset portfolios2715%−0.14
Calendar effects · all markets12616%−0.93
Intraday rules34718%−0.50

Signals that flipped

10 public signals looked significant before 2015 and then reversed more often than any random placebo signal did.

SignalFamilySignificant cellsKept direction
P4D_MOF_FOREIGN_JP_BONDSCross-border capital flows2252%
P4D_MOF_JP_FOREIGN_BONDSCross-border capital flows437%
P4D_MOF_JP_FOREIGN_EQUITYCross-border capital flows230%
P4D_SEC8K_ITEM_2_05Regulatory and corporate filings24113%
P4D_PHILLY_FUTUREExpectations and surveys1069%
CAL_YEAR_ENDCalendar13011%
P6D_SNB_SIGHT_CHG4Foreign central banks10812%
P6D_CASS_EXP_YOYFreight5114%
P6D_WSTS_BILLINGS_YOYSemiconductors200%
P4D_GPR_COUNTRY_SAUUncertainty and news1155%

Even in hindsight

Classic indicator rules on intraday bars lose after costs over the full history. See the backtest upper bounds.

Caveats

The 2015–2026 test window has been looked at many times during research, so we label it and do not call it a clean holdout. "Beat benchmark" compares each test with a fixed asset mix or buy-and-hold in the same window; a weak benchmark flatters the result. Many tests use US-listed ETFs.

Terms used: base rate, out-of-sample test, placebo test, dead end.

Before your next backtest

Let your AI check how ideas like yours did before it runs a single test. In our pilot, agents that checked first spent 1% of their backtests on known dead ends instead of 15%, and every backtest not wasted is time and tokens you keep. Cite this entry as ER-DEAD, as of 2026-11-01.

Questions

Which trading strategies do not work?

In our register: calendar effects and lead-lag signals on US equities, intraday timing rules and classic indicator rules on short bars, among others.