Base rate

Positioning signals (CFTC and others): base rate from 302 out-of-sample tests

By Justin JaegerPublished Updated

Positioning signals (CFTC and others) were tested 302 times across 25 idea variants. 30% beat their benchmark in 2015–2026 after costs, with a median Sharpe difference of −0.06. Verdict as of 2026-11-01: no consistent edge.

Key numbers

MeasureValue
Tests302
Idea variants25
Beat benchmark30.1%
Median Sharpe vs benchmark−0.06
Looked good before 201549
… and held after42.9%
VerdictNo consistent edge

By asset class

Asset classTestsBeat benchmarkMedian Sharpe vs bmVerdict
US equities14218%−0.10No consistent edge
international equities5432%−0.04No consistent edge
commodities4547%−0.01No consistent edge
currencies2462%+0.04No consistent edge
single stocks2227%−0.06No consistent edge

Caveats

The 2015–2026 test window has been looked at many times during research, so we label it and do not call it a clean holdout. "Beat benchmark" compares each test with a fixed asset mix or buy-and-hold in the same window; a weak benchmark flatters the result. Many tests use US-listed ETFs.

Terms used: base rate, out-of-sample test, placebo test, dead end.

Before your next backtest

Let your AI check how ideas like yours did before it runs a single test. In our pilot, agents that checked first spent 1% of their backtests on known dead ends instead of 15%, and every backtest not wasted is time and tokens you keep. Cite this entry as ER-POS-ALL, as of 2026-11-01.

Related evidence

Questions

Do positioning signals (CFTC and others) work?

Positioning signals (CFTC and others) were tested 302 times across 25 idea variants. 30% beat their benchmark in 2015–2026 after costs, with a median Sharpe difference of −0.06. Verdict as of 2026-11-01: no consistent edge.

Is this investment advice?

No. These are research statistics, not recommendations.