Base rate

Do moving-average crossover rules work? 38,761 backtests after costs

By Justin JaegerPublished Updated

Moving-average crossover rules were backtested 38,761 times on up to 557 symbols over their full history after retail costs. Only 9.3% beat cash (Sharpe above zero); the median Sharpe was −0.84. Even looking back, this is a dead end.

The golden cross vs doing nothing: $16,461 vs $35,144 since 2015

Key numbers

MeasureValue
Backtests38,761
Beat cash after costs9.3%
Median Sharpe−0.84

Why this is an upper bound

These backtests ran over the full history, including the period the rules were tuned on. That is the most favourable view a rule can get. If it loses here, it will not do better on new data.

All rule families

Rule familyBacktestsBeat cashMedian Sharpe
RSI zone rules84,4813.8%−1.09
MACD crossover rules81,5743.8%−1.12
Donchian breakout rules75,8654.6%−0.90
Bollinger squeeze rules46,9280.7%−1.61
Moving-average crossover rules38,7619.3%−0.84
Turtle soup (false breakout) rules8,8369.8%−0.92

Caveats

Sharpe here subtracts a 4% cash rate. Rules were combined with macro filters; costs follow a retail broker model. Some symbols had data errors that we did not correct for this layer.

Before your next backtest

Let your AI check how ideas like yours did before it runs a single test. In our pilot, agents that checked first spent 1% of their backtests on known dead ends instead of 15%, and every backtest not wasted is time and tokens you keep. Cite this entry as ER-IS-SMA_, as of 2026-11-01.

Related evidence

Questions

Do moving-average crossover rules work?

Moving-average crossover rules were backtested 38,761 times on up to 557 symbols over their full history after retail costs. Only 9.3% beat cash (Sharpe above zero); the median Sharpe was −0.84. Even looking back, this is a dead end.